User talk:CLCStudent/Archive 172

Page contents not supported in other languages.
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Archive 165 Archive 170 Archive 171 Archive 172 Archive 173 Archive 174 Archive 175

Reversion on Manisha Panchakam, warning given to new editor

Hi, I'm not entirely clear why you have reverted a new editor, Avdmoh, on this article, and further have given him a level 3 warning. The editor made these changes, which while uncited appear to me to be correct and by intention purely constructive. The reversion could be justified on the grounds that a citation might have been advisable, but in truth, the meaning of the material has not changed and for constructive copy-edits and small explanations, I'd not have thought any citation necessary. If I'm even half correct about that, the warning would seem to be inappropriate. I wonder what your thoughts are on the matter? We are in danger of losing a useful editor; he needs encouragement to learn to use sources, and will then be a valuable contributor. All the best, Chiswick Chap (talk) 13:51, 16 February 2020 (UTC)