Wikipedia:Featured and good topic candidates/Featured log/November 2016

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
edit2006
April 1 promoted 6 not promoted
October 0 promoted 1 not promoted
November 4 promoted 1 not promoted
December 1 promoted 2 not promoted 1 sup.
2007
January 2 promoted 7 not promoted
February 1 promoted 2 not promoted 0 sup. 1 demoted
March 1 promoted 4 not promoted 0 sup. 1 demoted
April 2 promoted 1 not promoted
May 2 promoted 4 not promoted 2 sup. 1 kept
June 3 promoted 2 not promoted
July 0 promoted 0 not promoted
August 1 promoted 0 not promoted
September 4 promoted 6 not promoted 1 sup.
October 4 promoted 1 not promoted
November 2 promoted 0 not promoted 2 sup.
December 3 promoted 1 not promoted
2008
January 3 promoted 0 not promoted 2 sup. 2 demoted
February 2 promoted 1 not promoted
March 4 promoted 2 not promoted 1 sup.
April 5 promoted 4 not promoted 0 sup. 1 kept
May 5 promoted 1 not promoted 1 sup.
June 2 promoted 0 not promoted 1 sup. 2 demoted
July 3 promoted 4 not promoted 1 sup.
August 7 promoted 5 not promoted 2 sup.
September 10 FT, 7 GT 14 not promoted 3 sup.
October 2 FT, 7 GT 7 not promoted 3 sup. 1 kept
November 2 FT, 5 GT 3 not promoted 4 sup.
December 7 FT, 11 GT 5 not promoted 2 sup.
2009
January 2 FT, 4 GT 5 not promoted 2 sup.
February 7 FT, 6 GT 1 not promoted 2 sup. 1 kept, 1 demoted
March 2 FT, 3 GT 2 not promoted 1 sup. 1 kept
April 3 FT, 1 GT 3 not promoted 0 sup.
May 2 FT, 3 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 1 demoted
June 4 FT, 9 GT 2 not promoted 3 sup. 3 demoted
July 2 FT, 6 GT 5 not promoted 3 sup. 2 demoted
August 2 FT, 6 GT 2 not promoted 1 sup.
September 3 FT, 2 GT 1 not promoted 2 sup. 2 kept
October 3 FT, 4 GT 0 not promoted 1 sup. 2 kept, 6 demoted
November 1 FT, 1 GT 1 not promoted 0 sup. 1 kept
December 1 FT, 5 GT 1 not promoted 0 sup.
2010
January 1 FT, 3 GT 1 not promoted 2 sup. 2 demoted
February 0 FT, 3 GT 2 not promoted 3 sup. 2 kept, 2 demoted
March 5 FT, 4 GT 3 not promoted 1 sup. 1 kept, 5 demoted
April 1 FT, 8 GT 3 not promoted 4 sup.
May 0 FT, 7 GT 0 not promoted 1 sup.
June 2 FT, 3 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 1 demoted
July 5 FT, 3 GT 2 not promoted 2 sup. 2 demoted
August 1 FT, 6 GT 0 not promoted 1 sup.
September 1 FT, 1 GT 4 not promoted 0 sup.
October 3 FT, 18 GT 4 not promoted 1 sup. 2 kept, 2 demoted
November 0 FT, 2 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 2 kept, 1 demoted
December 2 FT, 7 GT 1 not promoted 1 sup. 1 kept, 1 demoted
2011
January 2 FT, 5 GT 3 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
February 1 FT, 11 GT 1 not promoted 0 sup. 1 kept, 1 demoted
March 0 FT, 4 GT 2 not promoted 0 sup. 1 kept, 0 demoted
April 1 FT, 9 GT 1 not promoted 1 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
May 1 FT, 4 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 2 demoted
June 1 FT, 2 GT 2 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
July 2 FT, 2 GT 1 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 2 demoted
August 1 FT, 8 GT 2 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
September 2 FT, 2 GT 2 not promoted 1 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
October 4 FT, 6 GT 0 not promoted 2 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
November 1 FT, 2 GT 1 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
December 1 FT, 4 GT 1 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
2012
January 1 FT, 3 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
February 0 FT, 11 GT 0 not promoted 1 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
March 2 FT, 0 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
April 0 FT, 6 GT 1 not promoted 0 sup. 1 kept, 0 demoted
May 1 FT, 5 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 1 kept, 0 demoted
June 0 FT, 2 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
July 0 FT, 14 GT 1 not promoted 1 sup. 0 kept, 4 demoted
August 2 FT, 0 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
September 1 FT, 6 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 2 kept, 0 demoted
October 1 FT, 3 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
November 2 FT, 4 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
December 1 FT, 6 GT 0 not promoted 1 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
2013
January 0 FT, 3 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
February 0 FT, 3 GT 0 not promoted 1 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
March 2 FT, 2 GT 1 not promoted 1 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
April 2 FT, 4 GT 1 not promoted 0 sup. 2 kept, 0 demoted
May 0 FT, 5 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
June 1 FT, 0 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 1 kept, 1 demoted
July 1 FT, 8 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 3 kept, 2 demoted
August 1 FT, 2 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
September 0 FT, 4 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 1 kept, 0 demoted
October 4 FT, 1 GT 0 not promoted 1 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
November 1 FT, 1 GT 1 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
December 0 FT, 4 GT 1 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
2014
January 1 FT, 2 GT 0 not promoted 2 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
February 0 FT, 3 GT 1 not promoted 0 sup. 1 kept, 0 demoted
March 0 FT, 3 GT 1 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
April 1 FT, 0 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
May 1 FT, 0 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
June 2 FT, 4 GT 1 not promoted 2 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
July 1 FT, 3 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 1 kept, 0 demoted
August 4 FT, 1 GT 2 not promoted 2 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
September 1 FT, 5 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
October 1 FT, 2 GT 1 not promoted 1 sup. 0 kept, 2 demoted
November 1 FT, 1 GT 0 not promoted 1 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
December 1 FT, 0 GT 1 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
2015
January 0 FT, 2 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
February 0 FT, 1 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
March 1 FT, 1 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
April 0 FT, 2 GT 1 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
May 2 FT, 3 GT 1 not promoted 2 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
June 0 FT, 0 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
July 1 FT, 3 GT 0 not promoted 1 sup. 1 kept, 1 demoted
August 1 FT, 3 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
September 2 FT, 2 GT 0 not promoted 1 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
October 0 FT, 0 GT 1 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
November 1 FT, 2 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
December 1 FT, 2 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
2016
January 1 FT, 1 GT 0 not promoted 2 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
February 0 FT, 0 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
March 1 FT, 3 GT 0 not promoted 1 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
April 0 FT, 0 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 1 kept, 0 demoted
May 0 FT, 3 GT 1 not promoted 2 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
June 1 FT, 2 GT 0 not promoted 2 sup. 0 kept, 2 demoted
July 1 FT, 2 GT 1 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
August 1 FT, 3 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 1 kept, 1 demoted
September 0 FT, 7 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
October 0 FT, 3 GT 0 not promoted 3 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
November 0 FT, 4 GT 0 not promoted 1 sup. 1 kept, 2 demoted
December 0 FT, 1 GT 1 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
2017
January 2 FT, 3 GT 1 not promoted 1 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
February 0 FT, 3 GT 2 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
March 4 FT, 2 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 1 kept, 0 demoted
April 1 FT, 3 GT 0 not promoted 2 sup. 0 kept, 2 demoted
May 1 FT, 6 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
June 0 FT, 2 GT 0 not promoted 1 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
July 0 FT, 4 GT 0 not promoted 1 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
August 0 FT, 1 GT 1 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
September 0 FT, 1 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
October 0 FT, 1 GT 0 not promoted 1 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
November 1 FT, 0 GT 1 not promoted 0 sup. 1 kept, 0 demoted
December 1 FT, 2 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
2018
January 1 FT, 4 GT 0 not promoted 1 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
February 0 FT, 1 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
March 0 FT, 1 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
April 1 FT, 5 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 1 kept, 0 demoted
May 1 FT, 4 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
June 1 FT, 2 GT 1 not promoted 1 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
July 1 FT, 4 GT 1 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
August 1 FT, 2 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
September 0 FT, 3 GT 2 not promoted 1 sup. 1 kept, 0 demoted
October 1 FT, 1 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
November 0 FT, 1 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
December 0 FT, 3 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
2019
January 1 FT, 1 GT 4 not promoted 4 sup. 0 kept, 2 demoted
February 0 FT, 3 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
March 1 FT, 3 GT 2 not promoted 2 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
April 0 FT, 0 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
May 0 FT, 4 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
June 0 FT, 1 GT 1 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
July 1 FT, 2 GT 1 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
August 1 FT, 5 GT 1 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
September 0 FT, 0 GT 0 not promoted 1 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
October 1 FT, 2 GT 1 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 3 demoted
November 0 FT, 1 GT 1 not promoted 2 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
December 1 FT, 0 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
2020
January 0 FT, 0 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
February 1 FT, 5 GT 0 not promoted 2 sup. 0 kept, 5 demoted
March 3 FT, 1 GT 1 not promoted 0 sup. 1 kept, 0 demoted
April 0 FT, 0 GT 0 not promoted 1 sup. 1 kept, 1 demoted
May 1 FT, 2 GT 1 not promoted 3 sup. 2 kept, 4 demoted
June 0 FT, 8 GT 0 not promoted 2 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
July 0 FT, 2 GT 2 not promoted 1 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
August 1 FT, 2 GT 2 not promoted 1 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
September 0 FT, 3 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 2 demoted
October 0 FT, 5 GT 1 not promoted 2 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
November 1 FT, 0 GT 2 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
December 0 FT, 0 GT 0 not promoted 1 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
2021
January 0 FT, 3 GT 1 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
February 1 FT, 1 GT 1 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
March 0 FT, 4 GT 1 not promoted 1 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
April 0 FT, 1 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
May 0 FT, 4 GT 1 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
June 2 FT, 1 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 2 demoted
July 1 FT, 1 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
August 0 FT, 4 GT 0 not promoted 2 sup. 1 kept, 0 demoted
September 1 FT, 1 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
October 1 FT, 0 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
November 0 FT, 0 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
December 0 FT, 0 GT 1 not promoted 0 sup. 2 kept, 1 demoted
2022
January 0 FT, 4 GT 0 not promoted 2 sup. 2 kept, 3 demoted
February 1 FT, 0 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
March 0 FT, 2 GT 1 not promoted 1 sup. 0 kept, 3 demoted
April 1 FT, 1 GT 0 not promoted 2 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
May 1 FT, 1 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
June 2 FT, 0 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
July 0 FT, 0 GT 0 not promoted 1 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
August 0 FT, 2 GT 0 not promoted 2 sup. 0 kept, 3 demoted
September 2 FT, 3 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
October 1 FT, 5 GT 0 not promoted 2 sup. 0 kept, 2 demoted
November 0 FT, 1 GT 1 not promoted 1 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
December 0 FT, 0 GT 0 not promoted 1 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
2023
January 0 FT, 0 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
February 0 FT, 1 GT 0 not promoted 1 sup. 0 kept, 4 demoted
March 0 FT, 2 GT 0 not promoted 2 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
April 0 FT, 0 GT 0 not promoted 1 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
May 0 FT, 1 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
June 1 FT, 1 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
July 0 FT, 1 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 2 demoted
August 2 FT, 3 GT 0 not promoted 3 sup. 0 kept, 2 demoted
September 1 FT, 4 GT 0 not promoted 1 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
October 1 FT, 0 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
November 1 FT, 0 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
December 0 FT, 0 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
2024
January 2 FT, 6 GT 2 not promoted 7 sup. 0 kept, 5 demoted
February 0 FT, 0 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
March 1 FT, 1 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
April 1 FT, 7 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 1 kept, 1 demoted
May 0 FT, 2 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
June 0 FT, 0 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
July 0 FT, 0 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
August 0 FT, 0 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
September 0 FT, 0 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
October 0 FT, 0 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
November 0 FT, 0 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
December 0 FT, 0 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted

Good topic candidates: view - edit - history

Osvetnik-class submarine[edit]

Contributor(s): Peacemaker67

All three articles are GA-class, and were recently promoted to Military history A-class. --Peacemaker67 (click to talk to me) 10:58, 13 October 2016 (UTC)[reply]

If the articles are GA class, shouldn't they have the GA symbol by them.........? -- ChrisTheDude (talk) 11:44, 13 October 2016 (UTC)[reply]
My mistake. Peacemaker67 (click to talk to me) 22:03, 13 October 2016 (UTC)[reply]
  • Don't worry, I've made the book for you. :) Also, I support the nomination. Nickag989talk 11:02, 8 November 2016 (UTC)[reply]
  • Support good work. Iazyges Consermonor Opus meum 21:16, 4 November 2016 (UTC)[reply]
  • Support -- main article for the class and sub-articles for both ships in that class; looks pretty straightforward to me. Cheers, Ian Rose (talk) 06:45, 8 November 2016 (UTC)[reply]
  • Closed with a consensus to promote to Good Topic. -- 03:41, 23 November 2016 (UTC)[reply]


Commander Keen series[edit]

Contributor(s): PresN

Over this past summer, I've been working on a project that I've always wanted to get to: Writing good articles on the entire Commander Keen series of video games. Besides being a fond memory from my childhood, they're an important part of video game history- the two main trilogies of episodes proved the viability of IBM-compatible PCs for action-based video games like Super Mario Bros., kickstarted the shareware distribution model, invented the industry's longest-running in-joke, and launched id Software, which went on to basically invent the first-person shooter genre as an encore. With the help of thorough reviews by Indrian, J Milburn, and IDV, the whole package of series page, 6.5 main episodes, and 1 awkward and overlooked pseudo-remake sequel is ready to go! --PresN 15:47, 28 October 2016 (UTC)[reply]

  • Support. Nice job.--IDVtalk 19:21, 28 October 2016 (UTC)[reply]
  • Support that topic takes me back, awesome.  MPJ-DK  18:05, 29 October 2016 (UTC)[reply]
  • Support, unless someone wants to argue that there is a problem with one of the articles. Gamingforfun365 (talk) 03:47, 6 November 2016 (UTC)[reply]
  • Support - Did the hard work of translating book sources into quality GA Wikipedia articles, great to have a classic topic that meets the completeness and quality criteria. Judgesurreal777 (talk) 01:35, 21 November 2016 (UTC)[reply]
  • Closed with a consensus to promote to Good Topic. -- 03:28, 23 November 2016 (UTC)[reply]

No. 91 (Composite) Wing RAAF[edit]

Contributor(s): Ian Rose

This Good Topic Candidate follows on from a nomination for a similar but smaller formation, No. 90 (Composite) Wing, which was promoted to FT in December 2014. Whereas No. 90 Wing was formed to administer RAAF units in the Malayan Emergency, No. 91 Wing was the overarching organisation for RAAF units in the contemporaneous Korean War. At one stage this was going to be an FT nom, and I was just awaiting the main article's promotion to FA for that, but after some last-minute digging I found evidence that RAAF Transport Flight (Japan) was officially part of the wing for a short time, and therefore should technically be a part of this topic, meaning that we had more GAs than FAs -- that's how it goes sometimes... ;-) --Ian Rose (talk) 14:48, 22 August 2016 (UTC)[reply]


NWA World Historic Welterweight Champions[edit]

This topic is about the Lucha Libre, professional wrestling championship, the NWA World Historic Welterweight Championship and include Good Articles on all wrestlers to hold the championship to create a complete topic. There is a nav box that unites all subjects under one and I believe this hits all the marks for a Good Topic. Note: The image is of one of the champions, there is no free image of the championship itself, I did consider a CMLL logo (the company that promotes it) but thought a picture of the current champion would be better. Side note: Booking has been created.  MPJ-DK  01:35, 18 August 2016 (UTC)[reply]

Support - seems a complete topic and hopefully with the relative infrequency of title changes in Mexico it should be possible to keep on top of adding new articles as required..... -- ChrisTheDude (talk) 09:53, 1 September 2016 (UTC)[reply]
  • Five champions in six years, yes I feel confident I can keep up and get new articles to GA within the guidelines for Topics. Thanks for your support.  MPJ-DK  15:52, 20 September 2016 (UTC)[reply]
  • Support looks good and meets WP:WIAGT. - Yellow Dingo (talk) 07:34, 21 September 2016 (UTC)[reply]
  • Support -- article on the championship plus all champions to date seems like a complete topic. Cheers, Ian Rose (talk) 11:42, 8 October 2016 (UTC)[reply]
  • Closed with a consensus to promote to Good Topic. - GamerPro64 01:40, 11 November 2016 (UTC)[reply]