Jump to content

Talk:Edgar Bear Runner

Page contents not supported in other languages.
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

One Messed Up Article

[edit]

I am re-posting the comment I just posted at the talk page of this article's creator:

Hello, I have just given up on fixing up and salvaging your article Edgar Bear Runner, which probably should be deleted unless another editor has the stomach for a major overhaul. The erroneous info conflating the Jumping Bull Ranch shootout with the Wounded Knee incident was flat out inexcusable. I thought it would be easy going after I took care of that... But the rest of the article is so poorly written & organized, and some of your sources are simply atrocious, among the worst I have ever come across.

P.S. - I see from your talk page that you haven't exactly won accolades for your other editing either. <SIGH> Anomalous+0 (talk) 03:26, 17 November 2019 (UTC)[reply]