Wikipedia:Peer review/Max Guevara/archive1
Max Guevara[edit]
Toolbox |
---|
This peer review discussion has been closed. |
I've listed this article for peer review because i'd like to nominate it for GA eventually. I completely overhauled the article by myself so would like the opinions of other editors.
Thanks, Freikorp (talk) 11:36, 15 October 2015 (UTC)
- Closing this now as i've received one great review, it's been open for 3 weeks, and i'd like to nominate something else. Freikorp (talk) 13:11, 7 November 2015 (UTC)
Comments from RO[edit]
- Lead
- Split that first sentence into two.
- She also searchers for her "brothers and sisters"
- Creation and appearances
- Following his success with the film Titanic, director James Cameron teamed up with Charles H. Eglee.
- The Cameron quote might be too long, so consider trimming and/or paraphrasing.
- Attributes
- carried to term by a human woman
- Designed to be the perfect soldier, Max is extremely strong, athletic and agile. She can see in the dark, can zoom in with her eyes to view distant objects, does not need to sleep, and has a photographic memory.[9]
- She also has enhanced hearing, can leap up or down from great heights with ease, can hold her breath underwater for extended periods, and can dodge bullets with her super speed.[8] Max lies, cheats and steals when she needs to, and shows no remorse when doing so, though she is morally opposed to guns
- sits atop of the derelict Space Needle
- Max goes in heat.
- Storyline
- I find the bit about the prequel confusing, as it sounds like she was on the run before having escaped.
- Cale notices and recognises Max's barcode
- the even more ruthless Elizabeth Renfro
- In second two Logan exposes Manticore to the world
- The series ends with the military surrounding
- The last two paragraphs are without citations, but maybe this is okay with plot summaries
- Plots don't need sources; I'm not sure if adding the sources to the first two paragraphs mainly is appropriate but a) the sources were available (sources are much harder to find for season two and probably non-existent for the books) and it helps me add direct quotes which i feel improve the section. Freikorp (talk) 22:54, 30 October 2015 (UTC)
- Reception
- In October 2000 Howard Rosenberg said
- his list of the 100 sexiest women in sci-fi
- Conclusion
This is a very well-written piece overall. I wish it was more detailed though, but reliable sources might be hard to find. Make sure there aren't any BrEngisms, as per WP:ENGVAR this should be written in AmEng. Nice job; keep up the great work! RO(talk) 17:02, 30 October 2015 (UTC)
- Thanks so much for your comments Rationalobserver. I've replied to all of your concerns. Let me know if you think anything needs more work. Freikorp (talk) 22:59, 30 October 2015 (UTC)