User:Jéské Couriano/ArbEnfCount/ArchiveGroups/180s
Appearance
Blk | TBan | Warn | NEA | Decl | Acpt | PLS | Misc | NV | PE | STL | WD | NOR |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Block | Topic-ban | Warning | Non-enforcement | Declined appeal | Accepted appeal | Page-level sanction | Misc. | Moot/not a violation | Procedural error | Inconclusive | Withdrawn | Other decline reason |
Archive no. | Sanctions total | Thread | Arb case | Date of last post | Sanctions applied | Summary | Notes |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
181 | 1 block 1 topic-ban 1 warning 1 non-enforcement action 3 declined appeals 3 moot/not violations 2 procedural errors |
PraetorianFury | AP2 | Sep. 15, 2015 | PraetorianFury: Ban from same-sex marriage topic area (indef) | TBan | N/A |
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by A Quest For Knowledge | CC | Sep. 16, 2015 | -nil- | NV | Sanction being appealed lapsed on its own terms while thread was ongoing. | ||
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by BenMcLean | GG | Sep. 20, 2015 | BenMcLean: Ban from GG area remains in place. | Decl | The entire appeal was full of personal attacks against Gamaliel and extremely hyperbolic claims as to the article text. Admins took note of this and almost summarily declined the appeal. | ||
Arbitration enforcement request by IP editor | GG | Sep. 22, 2015 | -nil- | PE | The request was filed by an unregistered user and malformed. Even if it had been properly filed, it demanded that multiple users be subjected to Checkuser as a potential sockpuppet based off of what appears to be little more than a #chan-based conspiracy theory and would have been rejected for the privacy implications. | ||
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by Soham321 | IP | Sep. 22, 2015 | Soham321: Ban from India topic-area remains in place | Decl | Admins noted that their edits on Talk:Voltaire were attempts to import the banned topic-area into the article. | ||
Lanlan lanwan | PIA | Sep. 23, 2015 | Lanlan lanwan: Block (1w) | Blk | N/A | ||
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by Unbiasedpov | IP | Sep. 26, 2015 | Unbiasedpov: Ban from 2002 Gujarat riots topic-area remains in place. | Decl | N/A | ||
19999o | MAC | Sep. 28, 2015 | 19999o: Block (48h, non-enforcement) | NEA | N/A | ||
Gob Lofa | TRB | Sep. 28, 2015 | -nil- | NV | N/A | ||
DHeyward | BLP | Oct. 01, 2015 | DHeyward: Formally warned of BLP sanctions | Warn | N/A | ||
EllenCT | AP2 | Oct. 01, 2015 | -nil- | NV | Edits at issue were stale. | ||
John sargis | -- | Oct 01, 2015 | -nil- | PE | Filer was seeking sanctions for breaches of a community-authorised sanction. | ||
182 | 1 block 1 warning 1 successful appeal 1 inconclusive |
HughD | TPM | Oct. 11, 2015 | HughD: Warned to adhere to their topic ban | Warn | N/A |
VictorD7 | AP2 | Oct. 11, 2015 | -nil- | STL | Admins had issue with the complaint, as it was mainly presented as a wall of text coupled with a back-and-forth between filer and subject. Discussion ultimately petered out. | ||
BenMcLean | GG | Oct. 13, 2015 | BenMcLean: Block (24h) | Blk | BenMcLean talked himself into a block. | ||
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by Slovenski Volk | MAC | Oct. 14, 2015 | Slovenski Volk: Ban from Balkans topic-area lifted. | Acpt | N/A | ||
183 | 2 topic-bans 1 warning 2 non-enforcement actions 1 declined appeal 5 page-level sanctions 1 moot/not a violation 1 withdrawn |
Bachcell | BLP | Oct. 15, 2015 | Bachcell: Ban from Ahmed Mohamed topic-area (indef) | TBan | Gamaliel issued a topic-ban immediately given the extreme nature of the BLP violations, with consensus later being to make the sanction indefinite. |
Burridheut | MAC | Oct. 18, 2015 | Burridheut: Ban from Spiro Koleka topic-area (indef) | TBan | EdJohnston expressed concern that Burridheut was likely right on the content issues (though criticised his behaviour) and that the content at issue - Koleka's ethnicity - was not going to be easy to address given his birthplace was a ethnically-diverse (and contested) region. He also noted that the German Wikipedia outright removed Koleka's ethnicity from their article on him for this reason. | ||
DenisGusinje | MAC | Oct. 21, 2015 | DenisGusinje: Block (48h, non-enforcement), formally warned of MAC sanctions | Warn, NEA | N/A | ||
Caste articles and talk pages | IP | Oct. 22, 2015 | Nair (and its talk page), Jat people, Vanniyar, and Bhumihar: Extended-confirmed restriction (indef) | PLS x5 | While WP:GS/CASTE was in effect at this time, the filer wanted authorisation to put 500/30 restrictions per IP and not the general sanctions regime as the Arbitration remedy would be more difficult to unilaterally reverse. This was granted along with the page-level sanctions. | ||
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by Kyohyi | GG | Oct. 25, 2015 | Kyohyi: Appeal of ban from GG area withdrawn. | WD | N/A | ||
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by Burridheut | MAC | Oct. 29, 2015 | Burridheut: Ban from Spiro Koleka topic-area remains in place. | Decl | N/A | ||
(IPv4 address starting 74.) | PIA | Oct. 28, 2015 | (The aforementioned IPv4): Block (1w, non-enforcement) | NEA | N/A | ||
E.M.Gregory | PIA | Nov. 02, 2015 | -nil- | NV | Dismissed as a content dispute. | ||
184 | 1 topic-ban 1 warning 1 non-enforcement action 1 declined appeal 1 successful appeal 2 moot/not violations 1 procedural error 1 inconclusive |
HistoneSebas | PIA | Nov. 02, 2015 | Battle of Karameh: Full-protected (1w, non-enforcement) | NEA | HistoneSebas' actions weren't deemed to be breaches of the 1RR. but it was noted there was a slow-motion edit-war going on, prompting the full-protection to stamp it out. |
Anticyclone à banias | PIA | Nov. 02, 2015 | -nil- | NV | Anticyclone à banias opted to stop editing, making the request moot. They would, a month later, be indefinitely blocked as a sockpuppet. | ||
Justlettersandnumbers | -- | Nov. 02, 2015 | -nil- | PE | Retaliatory filing unrelated to any Arbitration over being admonished for copyright violations. | ||
Richard Arthur Norton (1958- ) | RAN | Nov. 09, 2015 | -nil- | NV | Matter referred to ARCA as it wasn't clear if Richard Arthur Norton (1958- )'s sanctions extended to replacing redirects with articles. (Arbitrators stated that they did.) | ||
Appeal of discretionary sanction topic ban violation block of HughD | TPM | Nov. 10, 2015 | HughD: Block remains in place. | Decl | N/A | ||
Nocturnalnow | BLP | Nov. 15, 2015 | -nil- | STL | Admins couldn't reach a consensus on any sanctions. | ||
Lvivske | EE | Nov. 13, 2015 | Lvivske: Ban from Azov Battalion topic-area (indef) | TBan | N/A | ||
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by Yossiea~enwiki | PIA | Nov. 18, 2015 | Yossiea: Block duration reduced to time served (i.e. block lifted) | Acpt | While Yossiea's initial block was deemed to be justified, the subsequent extension of it to indefinite was not. | ||
Onefortyone | 141 | Nov. 24, 2015 | Onefortyone: Warned against making personal attacks and edit-warring. | Warn | N/A | ||
185 | 3 topic-bans 2 warnings 1 moot/not a violation 2 withdrawn |
Jaakobou | PIA | Nov. 26, 2015 | Jaakobou: Warned to adhere to their topic-ban | Warn | Jaakobou attempted to get a carveout for his topic-ban for the edits at issue, which was declined. |
S Marshall | EC | Nov. 29, 2015 | QuackGuru (filer): Ban from EC area (6mo) | TBan | Foot-shot; thread deemed frivolous with regards to S Marshall and deemed to be part of QuackGuru's efforts to hound him from the EC area. | ||
Realskeptic | PS | Dec. 06, 2015 | Realskeptic: Ban from vaccination and autism topic-areas (indef) | TBan | N/A | ||
TruthIsDivine | GC | Dec. 07, 2015 | TruthIsDivine: Ban from GC area (indef) | TBan | Subject would also be blocked independent of the thread; said block would be extended to an indefinite block due to confirmed sockpuppetry. | ||
HughD | TPM | Dec. 07, 2015 | -nil- | NV | Edits at issue were deemed to not be covered by his topic-ban. | ||
Request for Full Protection --->via the ARB to exercising its defined Discretionary Powers regarding Electronic Cigarettes[sic] | EC | Dec. 12, 2015 | -nil- | WD | Request is also malformed, and amounts to demanding ArbCom issue a discretionary sanction. | ||
JzG | GMO | Dec. 18, 2015 | -nil- | WD | Had it not been withdrawn, the thread would likely have been considered moot due to JzG self-reverting. | ||
DrChrissy | GMO | Dec. 21, 2015 | DrChrissy: Warned to adhere to topic ban | Warn | The comments at issue were struck by DrChrissy. | ||
186 | 2 topic-bans 4 warnings 1 successful appeal 1 page-level sanction 1 not acted on for other reasons |
Mystery Wolff | EC | Dec. 22, 2015 | Mystery Wolff: Warned not to personalise content disputes with other editors | Warn | A topic-ban was initially put in place, but rescinded almost immediately after by the sanctioning admin as unjustified. |
CFCF | EC | Dec. 23, 2015 | CFCF: Warned against edit-warring | Warn | N/A | ||
Vergilden | GMO | Dec. 24, 2015 | Vergilden: Warned to adhere to 1RR in GMO area jps[i]: Warned to adhere to 1RR in GMO area Talk:Precautionary principle: 1RR notice appended |
Warn x2, PLS | N/A | ||
Ollie231213 | LGV | Dec. 24, 2015 | Ollie231213: Ban from LGV area (indef) | TBan | N/A | ||
Nocturnalnow | AP2 | Dec. 24, 2015 | Nocturnalnow: Ban from post-1932 American politics topic-area (indef) | TBan | Nocturnalnow defended themselves with a massive wall of text that also threw accusations at others. This defence wound up being a factor in imposing the indefinite topic-ban. | ||
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by Winkelvi | BLP | Dec. 26, 2015 | Winkelvi: Topic-ban from Rick Alan Ross rescinded | Acpt | Appeal accepted by the sanctioning administrator after Winkelvi removed the page from his watchlist. | ||
Minor4th | GMO | Jan. 06, 2016 | -nil- | NOR | Thread became stale. | ||
187 | 2 blocks 2 topic-bans 1 non-enforcement action 2 moot/not violations 1 not acted on for other reasons |
Volunteer Marek-personal attacks and incivility | EE | Jan. 07, 2016 | -nil- | NOR | Thread deemed to be an attempt to weaponise AE |
930310 | LGV | Jan. 07, 2016 | 930310: Ban from LGV area (indef) | TBan | N/A | ||
HughD | TPM | Jan. 07, 2016 | HughD: Block (1w) | Blk | N/A | ||
Mystery Wolff | EC | Jan. 09, 2016 | Mystery Wolff: Ban from EC area (indef w/ 6mo appeal intervals) | TBan | N/A | ||
SageRad | GMO | Jan. 07, 2016 | -nil- | NV | Thread deemed to be frivolous | ||
Athenean | MAC | Jan. 07, 2016 | -nil- | NV | Dismissed as a content dispute. | ||
Scjessey | AP2 | Jan. 07, 2016 | Mouse001 (filer): Block (indef, non-enforcement) | NEA | Foot-shot; filer blocked for relentless POV-pushing, BLP violations, and for being a likely sockpuppet | ||
Jytdog | GMO | Jan. 06, 2016 | DrChrissy (filer): Block (1w) | Blk | Foot-shot; thread deemed to be frivolous with respect to Jytdog and was filed in violation of an interaction ban | ||
188 | 4 topic-bans 1 warning 2 declined appeals 4 moot/not violations 1 procedural error 1 not acted on for other reasons |
Arbitration enforcement appeal by User:HughD | AP2 | Jan. 11, 2016 | HughD: Block remains in place. | Decl | N/A |
NewsAndEventsGuy (reported by NewsAndEventsGuy) | CC | Jan. 11, 2016 | -nil- | NV | Subject/filer self-reported their own topic-ban violation. Admins declined to take further action as they recognised the issue and were working to correct it. | ||
Kachelus | LGV | Jan. 14, 2016 | -nil- | NV | Subject took a hiatus from en.wp, making the request moot. | ||
Wiking | PIA | Jan. 12, 2016 | -nil- | PE | Subject not formally alerted to PIA sanctions. | ||
Lugnuts | LGV | Jan. 12, 2016 | Legacypac (filer): Warned against weaponising AE | Warn | Foot-shot; thread deemed to be an attempt to weaponise AE | ||
RolandR | PIA3 | Jan. 12, 2016 | -nil- | NV | Thread deemed to be frivolous | ||
Richard Arthur Norton (1958- ) | RAN | Jan. 14, 2016 | -nil- | NOR | Formal sanctions were considered to be counterproductive, as Richard was participating in a related discussion at the Incidents noticeboard. | ||
GreatGreen | LGV | Jan. 17, 2016 | GreatGreen: Ban from LGV area (indef) | TBan | N/A | ||
Dicklyon and Darkfrog24 | ATC | Jan. 22, 2016 | Darkfrog24: Ban from project-level discussions about quotation marks and styles (indef w/6mo appeal intervals) Dicklyon: Strongly encouraged to "voluntarily" accept a ban from project-level discussions about quotation marks and styles (indef w/6mo appeal intervals) |
TBan x2 | " I encourage Dicklyon to hold themselves to the [indefinite discussion topic-ban], but I'm not formally topic banning them at this point. However, Dickylon should note that this is without prejudice to a new AE action against them if anyone wishes." -Thryduulf, 14:46 Jan 22, 2016 | ||
BjörnBergman | LGV | Jan. 21, 2016 | BjörnBergman: 1RR in LGV area (6mo) | TBan | N/A | ||
TFBCT1 | LGV | Jan. 22, 2016 | -nil- | NV | Subject stopped making the edits at the locus of the thread | ||
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by Mystery Wolff | EC | Jan. 22, 2016 | Mystery Wolff: Ban from EC area remains in place. | Decl | Mystery Wolff's entire argument was that the sanctioning administrator was involved; this argument was frivolous and resulted in an almost summary decline. | ||
189 | 10 blocks 7 topic-bans 2 warnings 3 declined appeals 1 accepted appeal 9 moot/not violations 1 procedural error 3 inconclusive 4 not acted on for other reasons |
I was topic-banned from RT News for 6 months for "disruptive edits" and I challenge this assertion[sic] | EE | Jan. 22, 2016 | -nil- | PE | Request is grossly malformed. |
Canada Jack | LGV | Jan. 22, 2016 | -nil- | STL | The one responding admin seemed inclined to dismiss it as a content dispute. | ||
NorthBySouthBaranof | GG | Jan. 25, 2016 | -nil- | NV | "We're not going to block someone for submitting a terrible BLP to AFD. Nobody cares about this except GG partisans on both sides. Please edit the encyclopedia or find another website to use to argue." -Gamaliel, hatting thread | ||
AJB43 | PIA3 | Feb. 02, 2016 | -nil- | NV | Subject voluntarily agreed to adhere to the 500/30 restriction on the disputed page. | ||
HistoryWrite | PIA3 | Feb. 03, 2016 | HistoryWrite: Block (indef) | Blk | Indefinite block was marked as enforcement. It would be lifted in October following an appeal by email to the sanctioning administrator. | ||
Darkfrog24 | ATC | Feb. 04, 2016 | Darkfrog24: Ban expanded to the entire Manual of Style and related project-level discussions as regards quotation marks and styles (indef w/ annual appeal intervals) | TBan | N/A | ||
Jaqeli | AA2 | Feb. 06, 2016 | Jaqeli: Ban from AA2 area (indef) | TBan | N/A | ||
(IPv4 address starting in 96.) | PIA3 | Feb. 09, 2016 | (The aforementioned IPv4): Block (1w) | Blk | N/A | ||
CFCF | EC | Feb. 09, 2016 | -nil- | STL | Thread became stale. | ||
Prokaryotes | GMO | Feb. 05, 2016 | Prokaryotes: Ban from GMO area (indef) | TBan | N/A | ||
SageRad | GMO | Feb. 12, 2016 | SageRad: Voluntary ban from Bhopal disaster, Yvette d'Entremont, and Charles Eisenstein topic-areas (indef) | TBan | N/A | ||
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by Ollie231213 | LGV | Feb. 15, 2016 | Ollie231213: Ban from LGV area remains in place | Decl | N/A | ||
Darkfrog24[2] | ATC | Feb. 15, 2016 | Darkfrog24: Block (1w) | Blk | N/A | ||
Galassi | EE | Feb. 17, 2016 | -nil- | NV | Informal warning given to be more careful about their topic-ban, as Galassi had restored banned material inadvertantly with a revert. | ||
Semitransgenic | GMO | Feb. 18, 2016 | Semitransgenic: Ban from GMO area (indef) | TBan | Subject retired during the thread (and has not returned). | ||
(IPv6 address starting 2604:2000:) | PIA3 | Feb. 24, 2016 | (The aforementioned IPv6): Warned to stay off PIA articles (2 more IPv6 addresses): Block (IPv4 address): Block |
Blk x3, Warn | N/A | ||
Catflap08 | C&H | Feb. 21, 2016 | Catflap08: Block (1w) Hijiri88 (filer): Warned to adhere to their interaction ban with Catflap08 |
Blk, Warn | While the filing was a breach of Hijiri88's interaction ban, leniency was given as he had been told to file at AE. | ||
Athenean | EE | Feb. 21, 2016 | CometEncke (filer): Block (indef) | Blk | Foot-shot; subject blocked as an obvious sockpuppet created specifically to pick fights | ||
Darkfrog24[3] | ATC | Mar. 01, 2016 | Darkfrog24: Block (1yr + indef) | Blk | (N.B.: "1yr + indef" means the sanctioned user is indefinitely blocked, with the first year as Arbitration enforcement.) | ||
Arminden | PIA | Mar. 02, 2016 | -nil- | NOR | Formal sanctions considered disproportionate to the breach. (In other words, the violation was so minor/technical in nature that formal sanctions were considered unjustifiable.) | ||
Markus2685 | AA2 | Mar. 04, 2016 | -nil- | NOR | Admins deemed the situation was better dealt with at other venues, particularly SPI and AfD. | ||
Konullu | AA2 | Mar. 03, 2016 | -nil- | NV | Subject struck AfD comments at locus of thread. | ||
Malik Shabazz | AP2 | Mar. 04, 2016 | -nil- | NOR | Filer was seeking sanctions for actions taken in responce to deliberate provocation. | ||
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by Sir Joseph | AP2 | Mar. 05, 2016 | Sir Joseph: Ban from Bernie Sanders remains in place. | Decl | The topic-ban in question was only for 1w, and would lapse on its own terms two days after the appeal was formally closed. | ||
Jytdog | GMO | Mar. 10, 2016 | -nil- | NV | Subject self-reverted the edit in dispute. | ||
Gaijin42 | GC | Mar. 16, 2016 | -nil- | NV | Thread deemed to be frivolous | ||
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by Volunteer Marek | AP2 | Mar. 15, 2016 | Volunteer Marek: Ban from Bernie Sanders lifted wholesale. | Acpt | Administrators responding to the appeal found the ban to be completely unjustifiable, as Marek had only made one revert to the page and justified it on the talk page. | ||
Felsic2 | GC | Mar. 15, 2016 | -nil- | NV | Dismissed as a heated content dispute. | ||
Scjessey | AP2 | Mar. 16, 2016 | -nil- | NV | Thread deemed to be frivolous. | ||
Mrbrklyn | PIA3 | Mar. 20, 2016 | -nil- | NOR | Filer was attempting to reopen a loophole ArbCom closed in the 500/30 restriction; admins were unwilling to entertain this. | ||
I9Q79oL78KiL0QTFHgyc | GMO | Mar. 21, 2016 | -nil- | STL | Consensus was that Enforcement could not grant the sanctions sought, and encouraged the filer to take it to ArbCom. Short Brigade Harvester Boris made a serious suggestion to blanket-topic-ban all belligerents in the GMO area for six months, with any breaches being met with a siteban for the offender for the remainder of the ban; while this was liked it was seen as too extreme for AE. | ||
Chesdovi | PIA | Mar. 25, 2016 | Chesdovi: Ban from Zionism and Western Wall topic-areas and from introducing new Palestine-related material to articles that didn't have any to begin with (indef) | TBan | N/A | ||
Sinceouch2422 | FG2 | Mar. 25, 2016 | Sinceouch2422: Block (indef) | Blk | Subject indefinitely blocked as a topic-ban would result in effectively the same thing. | ||
Beautifulpeoplelikeyou | PS | Mar. 25, 2016 | Beautifulpeoplelikeyou: Ban from electronic harassment topic-area (indef) | TBan | N/A | ||
Nableezy | PIA | Mar. 31, 2016 | -nil- | NV | Diffs used were stale. | ||
190 | 2 blocks 4 topic-bans 1 warning 3 moot/not violations 2 inconclusive 1 withdrawn |
GHCool | PIA | Mar. 28, 2016 | -nil- | STL | Discussion stalled out. |
Conzar | PS | Apr. 04, 2016 | Conzar: Ban from vaccination topic-area (indef) | TBan | N/A | ||
ԱշոտՏՆՂ[ii] | AA2 | Apr. 05, 2016 | ԱշոտՏՆՂ: Block (72h), formally warned of AA sanctions | Blk, Warn | N/A | ||
FreeatlastChitchat | IP | Apr. 04, 2016 | FreeatlastChitchat: Block (1w) | Blk | There was also discussion of a 0RR, but that was rendered moot for the time being by the block, with no prejudice to reopening that discussion if behaviour after the block didn't improve. | ||
Askahrc | PS | Apr. 01, 2016 | Askahrc: Ban from Deepak Chopra topic area (indef) | TBan | In responce to a request for evidence from another editor, Askahrc had posted material on his talk page that required suppression due to WP:OUTING concerns (though the other editor noted he found none of the evidence provided, including the contents of the suppressed edits, credible), | ||
Cirt | C&J | Apr. 07, 2016 | -nil- | WD | No administrators replied before the thread was withdrawn, but a third-party editor called out the thread as frivolous | ||
No More Mr Nice Guy | PIA | Apr. 10, 2016 | -nil- | STL | Thread became stale. | ||
HughD | TPM | Apr. 12, 2016 | -nil- | NV | Thread dismissed as frivolous. It was noted there was a parallel discussion on the Incidents noticeboard about putting a mutual interaction ban in place between HughD and the filer. | ||
MarkBernstein | GG | Apr. 14, 2016 | MarkBernstein: Ban from GG area (indef) | TBan | N/A | ||
TripWire | IP | Apr. 22, 2016 | -nil- | NV | Dismissed as a content dispute. | ||
Monochrome Monitor | PIA | Apr. 22, 2016 | -nil- | NV | Dismissed as a content dispute/out of scope. | ||
HughD[2] | TPM | Apr. 25, 2016 | HughD: Existing ban extended to 6mo and expanded to include all conservative American politics regardless of article | TBan | N/A |
Footnotes
[edit]- ^ User exercised right to vanish
- ^ hy: Asholtngh (approx.)